37 writing methods. Each with its source.
Blue Pencil is an editor, not a ghostwriter. Every note it leaves names the method it rests on and how strong the evidence is.
- Tested in studies 13 controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Widely used practice 24 in wide use, not yet tested
We checked every endpoint last week. At this point in time, we have completed all the tests. Next comes the staged rollout.
Sentence · Suggestion
At this point in time, we have completed all the tests.
“At this point in time” can go. The meaning stays the same.
BasisCut what can goAdams et al. 2021Tested in studies
- Which method
- Where it comes from
- How strong the evidence is
Plan
Before the draft: who it is for, what it says, and in what order.
Know your reader and purpose Before the draft, say who it is for and what they should know or do after reading. The review checks the draft against it.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Writing brief
- Sources
-
- Flower & Hayes A Cognitive Process Theory of Writing 1981
- ISO ISO 24495-1:2023 Plain language 2023
Conclusion first In memos, emails and reports, the point or request comes in the first lines. The review says where yours first appears.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- Memos, emails, reports
- Sources
-
- U.S. Army AR 25-50 Preparing and Managing Correspondence 2020
- Rogers & Lasky-Fink Writing for Busy Readers 2023
One question per piece An essay is driven by the question it tries to answer. The review flags a thesis the body never tests.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- Essays
- Sources
-
- Bereiter & Scardamalia The Psychology of Written Composition 1987
Outline before drafting A few lines of plan before the draft. In experiments, outlining improved the quality of the finished text.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Outline
- Sources
-
- Ronald Kellogg Attentional overload and writing performance (JEP: LMC 14) 1988
One job per paragraph The outline view states each paragraph’s job in a few words. A paragraph whose job can’t be stated needs work.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Outline
- Sources
-
- Purdue OWL Reverse Outlining 2024
- William Strunk Jr. The Elements of Style, rule 8 1918
Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion For research papers, the review checks what sits in which section, such as results inside Methods or new results in the Discussion.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- Research papers
- Sources
-
- Sollaci & Pereira The IMRAD structure: a fifty-year survey (J Med Libr Assoc) 2004
Show the gap A paper’s introduction maps the field, shows what is missing, then says how this work fills it.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- Research papers
- Sources
-
- John Swales Genre Analysis (the CARS model) 1990
They say, I say An argument shows the view it answers, where your own claim begins, a likely objection, and why it matters. The review asks for what’s missing.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- Research papers; Essays
- Sources
-
- Graff & Birkenstein They Say / I Say 2006
No method in this step has been tested in studies yet.
Draft
Getting the words down without stopping to judge them.
Write with the door closed, revise with it open During a writing session, Blue Pencil and the review stay out of sight. Generating and judging compete for the same limited attention.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Write with the door closed
- Sources
-
- Flower & Hayes A Cognitive Process Theory of Writing 1981
- Ronald Kellogg A model of working memory in writing 1996
Keep your hand moving A session option: only the paragraph you are writing stays visible, so you go forward instead of fixing.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Write with the door closed
- Sources
-
- Peter Elbow Writing Without Teachers 1973
A session you don’t split A timed session of 25 or 50 minutes. Fixed breaks helped students keep concentration and motivation, though total output didn’t rise.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Write with the door closed
- Sources
-
- Biwer et al. Comparing “Pomodoro” breaks and self-regulated breaks (BJEP 93) 2023
Stop where you know what comes next Before you stop, write one line about what comes next. Next time the draft opens right there.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Sources
-
- Ghibellini & Meier Interruption, recall and resumption: a meta-analysis 2025
250 words a quarter hour A faint pace line by the quarter hour during a session. Trollope wrote with his watch in front of him.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Write with the door closed
- Sources
-
- Anthony Trollope An Autobiography 1883
A fixed daily amount Write a set amount at a set time. In Boice’s studies, people who wrote on a schedule produced several times more pages than those who waited for the mood.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Write with the door closed
- Sources
-
- Robert Boice Professors as Writers 1990
Capture ideas anywhere Hobbes walked with a notebook in his pocket and pen and ink in the head of his stick. One command drops a line into your Inbox draft.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Inbox
- Sources
-
- John Aubrey Brief Lives, on Thomas Hobbes c. 1680
No method in this step has been tested in studies yet.
Rest
Putting time between writing and rereading.
Let it rest Set a draft aside until tonight, tomorrow, next week or six weeks. When it’s ready, read it as a stranger would.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Let it rest
- Sources
-
- Steven Pinker The Sense of Style 2014
- Quintilian Institutio Oratoria, X.4 c. 95
Read it aloud Your device’s voice reads the draft or a passage, so you hear where it stumbles.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Read aloud
- Sources
-
- Anthony Trollope An Autobiography 1883
No method in this step has been tested in studies yet.
Revise
Rereading as an editor: structure first, then sentences.
Structure before sentences The review comes in three passes: structure, sentences, conventions. Experienced writers revise the whole for a reader; novices only swap words.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- Nancy Sommers Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Experienced Adult Writers 1980
- Editorial Freelancers Association Editorial services definitions 2024
Read as a first-time reader Blue Pencil reads as the reader you choose and marks where attention drops, what confuses, and what stays unanswered. It doesn’t rewrite.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Read
- Sources
-
- Nancy Sommers Revision Strategies of Student Writers and Experienced Adult Writers 1980
The curse of knowledge Experts forget what readers don’t know. The review flags terms used before they’re explained and steps you skipped.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- Steven Pinker The Sense of Style 2014
Less is more Fewer ideas and fewer requests per message. In a field experiment, a 49-word email got almost twice the replies of a 127-word one.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- Memos, emails, reports
- Sources
-
- Rogers & Lasky-Fink Writing for Busy Readers 2023
Cut what can go Blue Pencil looks for dispensable words, sentences and paragraphs first. Asked to improve a text, most people only add words.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Sources
-
- Adams et al. People systematically overlook subtractive changes (Nature 592) 2021
- William Strunk Jr. The Elements of Style, rule 13 1918
The second draft is shorter The status bar shows how much shorter this version is than the longest one. A common rule of thumb is about a tenth.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Sources
-
- Adams et al. People systematically overlook subtractive changes (Nature 592) 2021
Actions as verbs Put the action in a verb and the actor in the subject: decide, not make a decision.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Applies to
- For text in English and Spanish
- Sources
-
- Joseph M. Williams Style: Lessons in Clarity and Grace 1981
Known first, new last Start a sentence with what the reader knows and end with what’s new. The active voice is suggested only when it also does this.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- Gopen & Swan The Science of Scientific Writing (American Scientist 78) 1990
- Geoffrey K. Pullum 50 Years of Stupid Grammar Advice 2009
Plain words Short, common words and straightforward sentences, so the reader spends attention on the idea.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- ISO ISO 24495-1:2023 Plain language 2023
- Rogers & Lasky-Fink Writing for Busy Readers 2023
Ask before changing meaning Where a change would alter meaning, facts or voice, the note is a question for you, not new wording.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- The Chicago Manual of Style 18th ed., §2.75 Author queries 2024
Find the exact word A vague word gets a question about what you mean, not a list of synonyms.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- Mark Twain letter to George Bainton, in The Art of Authorship 1888
Phrasing that sounds machine-written Stock transitions, hedging, tidy triads and empty intensifiers. The check looks at rhythm and clarity, not punctuation alone.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Review
- Sources
-
- Kobak et al. Delving into LLM-assisted writing through excess vocabulary (Science Advances 11) 2025
- Poynter Humans are trying not to sound like AI 2026
A style sheet per draft Your first choice of spelling, term or notation becomes the rule for this draft, and later variants are flagged against it.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Sources
-
- The Chicago Manual of Style 18th ed., §2.61 Editorial style sheet 2024
Punctuation by the language’s standard Each language keeps its own marks: opening ¿ and ¡ in Spanish, full-width marks in Chinese and Japanese. The local check flags mixed marks.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Sources
-
- The Chicago Manual of Style 18th ed., ch. 6 Punctuation 2024
- Real Academia Española Ortografía de la lengua española 2010
No method in this step has been tested in studies yet.
Habit
Writing regularly, and starting again after a missed day.
If-then writing plans “On weekdays after lunch, I open chapter three for 25 minutes.” The best-supported habit method we found. Add it to your calendar.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Writing habits
- Sources
-
- Gollwitzer & Sheeran Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis 2006
See small progress The weekly view shows what moved: words written and words cut. Progress on meaningful work was the strongest motivator measured.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Writing habits
- Sources
-
- Amabile & Kramer The Progress Principle 2011
Missing a day is fine Nothing resets when you skip a day. Missing once didn’t hurt habit formation; missing twice in a row is what to avoid.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Writing habits
- Sources
-
- Lally et al. How are habits formed (EJSP 40) 2010
Schedule the time Allot writing time like a class you wouldn’t cancel, rather than waiting to find it.
- Evidence
- Tested in studies: controlled experiments, meta-analyses or field trials
- Used in
- Writing habits
- Sources
-
- Robert Boice Professors as Writers 1990
- Paul J. Silvia How to Write a Lot 2007
A writing log A daily bar of words written. Trollope kept a weekly page diary for every book.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Writing habits
- Sources
-
- Anthony Trollope An Autobiography 1883
Read more, write more, discuss more Bacon’s three: reading for fullness, conversation for readiness, writing for exactness. Discussing is the part a reader or an editor can give you.
- Evidence
- Widely used practice: in wide use, not yet tested
- Used in
- Read
- Sources
-
- Francis Bacon Of Studies (Essays) 1625
No method in this step has been tested in studies yet.
Rules that apply only to text in another language appear when you write in it.
Sources, from the first century to 2025
- c. 95QuintilianInstitutio Oratoria, X.4
- 1625Francis BaconOf Studies (Essays)
- 1883Anthony TrollopeAn Autobiography
- 1888Mark Twainletter to George Bainton, in The Art of Authorship
- 1918William Strunk Jr.The Elements of Style, rule 13
- 1981Flower & HayesA Cognitive Process Theory of Writing
- 2006Gollwitzer & SheeranImplementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis
- 2021Adams et al.People systematically overlook subtractive changes (Nature 592)
- 2025Kobak et al.Delving into LLM-assisted writing through excess vocabulary (Science Advances 11)
Not affiliated with or endorsed by the writers or estates cited.